Home › Risk Radar › Article

Peak Property and Casualty Insurance: What You Need to Know

hereth insurance consulting - peak property and casualty insurance - House Keys In Hand

Table of Contents

What Is Peak Property and Casualty Insurance Corporation?

Peak Property and Casualty Insurance Corporation is a non-standard auto insurer, incorporated on August 16, 1985, that a Delaware regulator describes as licensed in 39 states and that now sits inside the Sentry Insurance Group.

The company began life under the ownership of General Electric Capital Mortgage Corporation and then moved through a chain of corporate parents before Sentry took it in. That history matters because ownership changes leave their trail in regulators’ reports, which is where this article draws its facts.

Demotech’s company page shows a Financial Stability Rating graphic labelled NR, together with the group name and one extra metric that comes up later in this article. In my experience, a label like that works better as a prompt to read the examination reports than as a verdict, and the sections below do exactly that.

Where Did Peak Come From, and Who Sits Behind It Today?

Peak Property and Casualty Insurance Corporation traces back to the mid-1980s and now operates as one member of the Sentry Insurance Group, whose companies provide the coverage and safety services its customers receive.

Its first Florida policy was issued in December 1999, and the program was sold through independent agents. Regulators have examined the company repeatedly: Florida’s examiners covered January 2001 through July 2002, began work on September 8, 2002 and finished on December 21, 2002, while Delaware’s later review was performed as of May 31, 2016.

Today the company is domiciled in Wisconsin and shares the Sentry roster with Patriot General Insurance Company and Dairyland County Mutual Insurance Company of Texas, among other carriers. I find it helps to picture that roster as a family tree with a single headquarters, because questions about who answers for a policy tend to lead back to one address.

What Does Peak Sell, and Where Is It Licensed?

Peak Property and Casualty Insurance Corporation sells personal auto coverage in dozens of states, but it does not appear among the carriers listed for California licensing on the Sentry brand page.

That page names three carriers under its state heading, and the table below sets two of them beside Peak, using the NAIC numbers from the page’s own company table.

CompanyNAIC numberNamed under the state heading?
Sentry Insurance Company24988Yes
Middlesex Insurance Company23434Yes
Peak Property and Casualty Insurance CorporationGiven in the next sectionNo

Demotech’s page adds a Reinsurance Utilization Measure of 90% to 100% of Premium, a figure worth weighing next to the rating graphic instead of ignoring it.

Operationally, Florida’s report found a general agency acting as managing general agent without an appointment and asked Peak to appoint it and pay a $60 fee. The same report describes equity billing, in which the insured is billed a month ahead of the next installment.

In North Carolina, filings for the personal auto line were made by the North Carolina Rate Bureau on Peak’s behalf, while Peak itself reported any rate deviations to the Department.

Which Sentry Companies Sit Alongside Peak?

Peak Property and Casualty Insurance Corporation, carrying NAIC number 18139, belongs to a Sentry group whose property and casualty coverages are underwritten by members based in Stevens Point, Wisconsin.

The Dairyland brand shows how that works in practice, since the NAIC table on its licensing page names seven carriers and Peak is one of them.

Ownership reached Peak indirectly. Sentry took 100% indirect ownership on November 1, 2005, when it acquired Viking Insurance Company of Wisconsin from Royal & SunAlliance USA, Inc., an acquisition that pulled Peak into the group along with it.

Peak’s home office is at 1800 North Point Drive, ZIP code 54481, the same street address shown in the footer of the brand’s website. I treat a shared address like that as a reason to read a group’s filings together rather than company by company.

What Does Demotech's Page Say About Peak?

Demotech’s page for Peak Property & Casualty Insurance Corporation files the company under the NAIC Group named Sentry Insurance Group, and it shows a rating graphic plus one extra metric rather than a narrative report.

Sentry’s own website confirms the grouping, because the Sentry Group of Companies list there includes Peak Property and Casualty Insurance Corp. alongside the group’s other carriers.

A one-page company record cannot show scale, so regulator reports fill the gap. In Florida alone, direct premiums written came to $5,780,045 on 12,222 policies for 2001, while Delaware’s report says Peak’s 2015 annual statement showed $168,251,598 in individual auto direct premiums written. North Carolina’s examiners, for their part, sampled from a population of 40,238 active policies.

Reading those figures side by side is how I judge whether a rating graphic deserves weight, since a single metric on one page rarely settles the question.

What Did Florida's 2003 Examination of Peak Find?

Florida’s 2003 market conduct report found errors in Peak’s policy files, cancellation notices, complaint handling and claim records, in the auto program the company marketed there as OrionAuto.

The report places Peak’s 1999 purchase inside the Orion Capital Corporation acquisition. Examiners were reacting to consumer complaints about rating and claim delays, so they sampled 100 policy files, 100 cancellation and nonrenewal files, 112 claim files and 68 complaint files.

Notices drew the most visible mistakes. Of 80 cancelled policies, 12 carried errors, and every one of the 20 nonrenewed policies drew an error. Ten of those errors involved dishonored checks, because applicants were not given a chance to pay before an ab initio cancellation.

Claims handling slipped in smaller ways. A loss wages payment under injury coverage reached the insured more than a year after the loss, and Peak owed $72.98 in interest. Another file sat idle until a $927.69 vehicle-damage check went out following a state complaint, and seven errors involved personal injury protection requirements.

hereth insurance consulting - peak property and casualty insurance - Home Documents And Keys

How Did Peak Handle Cancellations and Nonrenewals in Florida?

Peak’s cancellation and nonrenewal practices in Florida produced 32 errors across 100 reviewed files, mainly because policyholders did not receive the advance notice the statutes require.

Peak wrote six and twelve months policies and relied on a self-cancelling notice. The notice carried its print date rather than its mailing date, and mailing added about three days to a required notice period of ten or 45 days, so any delay in the mail ate into the notice the insured was owed.

In the report’s overall tally, cancellations and nonrenewals accounted for 32 of the 71 errors, close behind the 33 found in policy files.

The Florida Office of Insurance Regulation asked Peak to revise the wording and dates on its renewal notices and to document the fix within 90 days of receiving the report.

What Did Florida Find on Claims, Complaints and Corrective Actions?

Florida’s claims review of Peak found only two errors, both involving claim files the company could not locate, and the corrective actions the report required reached well beyond claims.

The claims sampled covered property damage, comprehensive and collision coverage, and a separate group of injury claims drew no errors at all. Peak does not write bodily injury or uninsured motorist coverage in Florida.

Across the whole examination, 380 files were reviewed, and the complaint portion produced three errors, one of them a failure to pay an injury-benefit bill within the allowed window.

The report asked for these fixes:

  • File the company’s underwriting guidelines, which had been revised four times without a filing.
  • File the company’s Anti-Fraud Plan with the state’s Division of Fraud.
  • Reword the notice of renewal premium so every insured gets 30 days of notice.
  • Appoint the unappointed general agency and pay its appointment fee.

Why Did North Carolina Examine Peak in 2015?

North Carolina examined Peak in 2015 through a target examination prompted by market analysis of youthful operators and the extra charge new drivers trigger.

The review began on August 24, 2015 and covered June 1, 2014 through May 31, 2015, with analysis continuing to November 6, 2015. Examiners worked from Peak’s regional office in Middleton, Wisconsin and from the Department’s Raleigh office, which makes it a different animal from a desk audit.

The examiners concentrated on private passenger automobile files. Fifty-nine policies were not endorsed when a youthful operator’s license level changed, 14 carried the wrong charge, ten were issued without it, and 35 were rated with voluntary rates instead of facility rates. Facility rates mattered because those policies were ceded to the North Carolina Reinsurance Facility.

Delaware’s later review looked at independent medical examinations and surcharges after an at-fault accident and found no exceptions, so the two states reached very different results from very different starting points.

What Did Delaware's 2016 Examination Conclude?

Delaware’s 2016 examination of Peak turned up nothing to correct and ended without a single recommendation.

Examiners reviewed all sixteen files in Peak’s small universe: six medical-exam files and ten surcharge files. North Carolina, by contrast, sampled with Audit Command Language at a 95% Confidence Level and drew 119 policies at random, and its findings centred on the inexperienced operator surcharge.

Delaware’s report also retells Peak’s corporate path. The company took its present name on July 10, 1991, and Guaranty National Insurance Company acquired it in 1993. When the R&SA insurance group bought Orion Auto, Inc. and all its subsidiaries on November 16, 1999, those subsidiaries included that carrier.

The last step was a change of legal home. Peak was redomesticated from Colorado to Wisconsin on December 15, 2006, and Wisconsin has been its legal home since. Side by side, the three examinations looked like this.

RegulatorReview typeFocusResult
FloridaMarket conductConsumer complaints about rating and claim delaysErrors across files, notices, complaints and claims
North CarolinaLimited-scope market conductYouthful operators and ratingViolations with corrective directives
DelawareOff-site reviewClaims after medical exams and post-accident rating chargesNothing to correct, no recommendations
hereth insurance consulting - peak property and casualty insurance - Open Door Lock

How Can I Reach Peak Insurance Customer Service?

WalletHub says the easiest way to reach Peak Insurance customer service is by phone at (334) 872-2303, but that answer describes a company with branches in Selma, Birmingham and Auburn, Alabama, which appears to be a different business from the Wisconsin insurer covered above.

The same WalletHub answer lists a fax line at 334-875-8225. For Peak Property and Casualty itself, Delaware’s report says Sentry furnishes service to policyholders under an administrative services agreement, and the Sentry brand page shows 1-800-334-0090 for its own brand support.

Treat any number you find online with caution. Sentry’s legal disclaimer says its website information is distributed as-is, without warranties, so confirm a phone number against your policy documents before relying on it.

Frequently Asked Questions About Peak Property and Casualty Insurance

What is Peak Property and Casualty Insurance Corporation?

Peak Property and Casualty Insurance Corporation is an insurer in the Sentry Insurance Group with NAIC number 18139. Dairyland’s website lists it as one of the underwriting companies behind the Dairyland, Dairyland Cycle, and Dairyland Auto brands.

Sentry Insurance Group owns Peak. Sentry took 100 percent indirect ownership on November 1, 2005, when it acquired Viking Insurance Company of Wisconsin. Dairyland Insurance Company is a sister company under the same group.

No. Dairyland is a brand and an insurer within the Sentry group, while Peak is a separate legal company that can underwrite Dairyland-branded policies. Your declarations page shows which company issued your policy.

Yes. AM Best rates Peak A+ (Superior) with a stable outlook and affirmed the rating on July 29, 2026. The rating rests on the consolidated financials of the Sentry Insurance Group.

I found no public quote page under the Peak name. Ask an independent agent or request a Dairyland quote, and then confirm which company issues the policy before you pay.

Check your declarations page or ID card for the claims contact. Dairyland lists 1-800-334-0090 as its main customer line. Report the loss promptly, save your claim number, and follow up in writing.

Dairyland’s underwriting page lists Peak in 39 states and the District of Columbia. It does not list Peak for California, Hawaii, Illinois, Maine, Michigan, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Vermont, or Wyoming.

I could not confirm that Peak sells homeowners insurance to the public. If an agent offers a Peak home policy, request the declarations page and verify the product with your state department of insurance.

Insurance Agency Columbia MO - Jordan Hereth with Hereth Insurance Consulting
Jordan Hereth
Licensed Insurance Advisor
Hereth Insurance Consulting — Columbia, MO
Jordan Hereth is the Principal Agent at Hereth Insurance Consulting, an independent insurance agency in Columbia, Missouri. He helps individuals, families, and businesses find practical insurance solutions designed around their specific needs and risks.

Found this helpful? Share it with a fellow business owner.

Need coverage advice?

Our team is here to help. One call gets you clear answers and real options.

or call 573-475-4015

Subscribe
Get insurance insights delivered to your inbox.